Scott Greer, IQ-187, on CPT v CRT


Posted On: Friday - July 18th 2025 10:45AM MST
In Topics: 
  Trump  Pundits  Globalists  alt-right/MAGA  ctrl-left  Deep State



There's plenty more stupidity on the front burner, readers, but I wanted to finish this - I cannot unread that Scott Greer substack post on his Critical Pedo Theory versus Critical Race Theory (and nothing against the guy, generally, either). Our previous post on this interesting analogy was a criticism of Steve Sailer's general "Nothing to see here!" attitude on evil in the world, as elucidated very nicely by commenter Anti-Gnostic. Here I will discuss Scott Greer's idea, with no oops, minimal reference to Mr. Sailer's opinion.

The idea is pretty nice, if it were correct: Just as Conservatives - let's just say MAGA here - have had the bogus Critical Race Theory pushed on them, MAGA has been pushing Critical Pedo Theory. The equivalence is supposed to be that the ctrl-left promoted CRT falsely, and maliciously too, IMO, uses race to blame White people, including MAGA, for all ills, while MAGA promoted CPT falsely, and maliciously too, I think Mr. Greer claims, uses pedophilia to blame the ctrl-left including the Globalists for all ills. If I haven't explained this well enough in that run-on sentence, let me paste in one intro paragraph from Mr. Greer:
This issue is important to much of the Right due to the belief in “Critical Pedo Theory.” This notion imagines that the world is ruled by a pedophile cabal and “systemic pedophilia” is inherent to the current order. These elite pedos are evil by nature, which is why they use space lasers to cause forest fires and wield their weather machine against red states. These right-wingers hoped Trump would battle the cabal as president. QAnoners thought he did so in his first term, clinging to fake news stories about the admin secretly arresting and executing prominent child molesters.
No, MAGA hoped that Trump would actually battle the Deep State - pedos or non-pedos. Mr. Greer claims the the Pedo Theory is a response to CRT, a way of calling the ctrl-left a name even worse than, GASP!, "racist":
Critical Pedo Theory emerged in the mid-2010s. It gained credence as a response to the Left. For years, liberals would condemn right-wingers as racists. Racism is one of the great taboos in American society. The other is pedophilia, so right-wingers began calling leftists kid diddlers to defang racism accusations. The Right’s embrace of conspiratorial populism transformed this rhetoric into CPT. Conservatives were no longer just calling the Left pedos to defend against racism smears–they now concocted an entire worldview centered on pedo cabals. Pizzagate and QAnon soon followed.
To "defang racist accusations"? That's asinine. Anyway, Mr. Greer admits that pedophilia is abhorred by generally everyone:
While the Right at times challenges the Left’s depiction of racism, the Left shares the Right’s moral revulsion towards pedophilia.
Well, yeah, there's a difference, as racism is not a particularly evil thing at all - the word is used by the ctrl-left to scare White people and to promote apportioning out their equity. (h/t, iSteve). CRT is a lie, but that doesn't mean that we all shouldn't be against pedophilia. Is this CPT a lie? That depends on how you define it.

I have never seen that T-shirt he mentions (non-excerpted) on anyone, not all MAGA reads Q-Anon, and no, the belief in pedo cabals or that the ctrl-left is a bunch of pedophiles is not a MAGA worldview or some overarching theory. That doesn't mean that there aren't Globalist elites who might partake in some wild, wacky stuff. (h/t Johnny Carson). We just don't think the average antifa Commie, a BLM thug, or those nice but usefully-idiotic neighbors with their "There are no illegal people" signs are "into it!"
A critical tenet of CPT is the belief that the Left will eventually try to legalize sex with minors. This became a common belief among conservatives following the legalization of gay marriage. It was feared the Left may take up pederasty normalization as its next cause.
Per Steve Sailer, the next thing, after (which Mr. Greer forgot about) his accurately-predicted Tranny thing, was going to be Polygamy. (Oh, well, it's hard to bat 100% with this stuff, and he's admitted he doesn't like doing predictions.) MAGA is pleased with Trump's work in battling all of the toxic stupidity of the left, such as D.I.E./AA and the pushing of BLT-G++. I don't think the ctrl-left would have been able to get far pushing pedophilia even without Trump.

Mr. Greer admits a different between CRT and CPT, in that the former has been pushed on us by academia, while the latter is speculation from these low-brow people of MAGA and the alt-right. That's a big difference. CRT has been taught in schools where paying customers (often the taxpayers) have no say in the matter. CRT has been used to control and humiliate regular people. This CPT, if anything, involves none of that. MAGA is not using CPT to indoctrinate anyone. If it is supposedly this worldview theory (NOT!), nobody is teaching that to the kiddies in school. It's just some stuff on the internet. CRT is real enough such that President Trump had to make many rulings to work to shut it down.

Like Mr. Sailer, Scott Greer feels himself above the low-brow people of the left and right. He has this brilliant analogy of parallel false beliefs, as this makes they high-brow folks much smarter and more civil. Nah, maybe the latter is true but not the former.)
Many Americans want to believe we are ruled by pedos. They want to think we’re ruled by the most evil people imaginable and these scumbags try to hide their dark secrets from the world. But the people are finally learning about this forbidden truth and waking up. Jeffrey Epstein allegedly proves it, as does the government covering up his crimes. They want the dead financier’s list, which they believe includes much of Congress. The idea that it might bring the whole system down makes it even more attractive. That’s what these populists want and believe we deserve. The fact that the release of just one document can have such a revolutionary impact further cements the appeal of CPT.

There’s basically no way to correct the new faiths created by the internet. CPT will remain a powerful part of the Right. It may even start to influence the Left as well.

Trump’s only hope for retaining these followers is banking on people’s short attention spans. MAGA will eventually move on to other subjects and forgive or forget about Trump not releasing the alleged Epstein list. But nothing can convince them that there is no pedophile cabal ruling the world. It’s fundamental to the conspiratorial populist’s belief system. Trying to persuade them is like trying to convince a devout Christian that there is no Hell.
Ahhh, nah. If you were to take out "pedo" and "pedophile" from all he wrote there, it'd still be true. MAGA people understand that not everything being done to the world is just "botched" or a misunderstanding. There IS evil.

I was informed that ZeroHedge has posted this Scott Greer article too - it's under the umbrella of some "Portfolio Armor" guy (from the name, I guess some guy with financial advice to sell) here. Regarding this Critical Pedo Theory, ZH commenters are pretty Critical. Every one I read is. Here's my favorite, by one Sam Lowrey**:
Ummmmm, no.

Mocking people who smell a rat in this whole Epstein Island saga is not going to make it go away Scottie!

I would venture to say that many of what you call MAGA Trump supporters had to hold their nose to vote for the guy. He's a authoritarian, bomb thrower, loose cannon, egomaniac and not quite all there, but he's still better than whatever that was that the DNC rolled up on stage.

Now, I don't have any idea who you are, but you are a moron if you can't make the very short leap to the conclusion that what was happening on Epstein Island and other isolated locales, was a classic Honey Trap......and that the US Government at least tolerated it, if not outright was the main SPONSOR it!

Also, you can't deny the ties to Israel. Glenn Greenwald does a fantastic job at explaining it here: https://rumble.com/v6w7mwm-evidence-of-epsteins-ties-to-israeli-intelligence-explained.html

Also, to lump all Trump "backers" into the same Q Anon boat is childish and misinformed. If it was an attempt at humor, you didn't succeed.

I believe the American people actually DON'T WANT TO BELIEVE that their government is capable of something like this. But, with accelerating speed, the facts have been blasting at us through our eyes and ears, that we can't deny. The lies our Government has told us over the past 10 years is lengthy and scarring.

Here's a short list:

1.) The Russia, Russia, Russia hoax

2.) The Steele Dossier Lie

3.) The COVID Vaccine Lie

4.) The Ukraine Impeachment Lie

5.) Hunter's laptop is Russian disinformation Lie

This article is just a sophomoric attempt at calling those who want answers, CONSPIRACY THEORISTS. That is not effective any more Scott. For a guy with an IQ of 187, I would've thought you'd know that!
That wasn't directly addressing Mr. Scott's main thesis, but... yeah.

Here's some more supposed evidence for the writer's analogy of CPT :: CRT:
CPT explains why Angel Studios, a conservative-ish film company, has done so many films on human trafficking. Its biggest success, Sound of Freedom, featured a former government agent going around rescuing kids from the implied clutches of the pedo cabal. CPT even inspired some of the Right’s immigration restriction, with fears that illegal migrant kids were being delivered to the cabal becoming a frequent criticism of Joe Biden’s open borders.
I saw this movie but was not impressed with the save-the-brown-people at the expense of your family stupidity of it. (See some commentary from PS along with Mike Tre's review.) I will say that, yes, the linking of some actual (there is LOTS) trafficking of minors, mostly by foreigners themselves, to the treasonous Dark Brandon/Mayorkas 10-12,000,000 foreigner invasion was a good move. It was mostly for the purposes of cheap labor, extra representation and votes, and, overarchingly, population replacement, but I'm sure some pedophiles folks in high places ordered up some kids too.

Also, as with the talk about Big Mike, Macron’s tranny husband wife, etc., some of this is said out of pure ridicule. It's all we've got sometimes.

However, there HAVE been strange things going on within the world of the super-rich elite. That’s not the main point of MAGA's great concern with the Epstein story. The “personnel” on Fantasy Island weren’t little toddlers, and they weren’t abducted. (They were naive, and their parents were obviously extremely careless and stupid.) My contention is, if Trump is on the client list, and he just told his family and then Americans the truth, MAGA would move on. It’s not about the young chicks. It’s about the blackmail, stupid!

Man, if this Greer guy has an IQ of 187, then I gotta be at least a 212 or somethin’! Only time, or AI, will tell...


PS: As he reached for evidence that "pedophile!" is the new "racist!", Mr. Greer made a good point here He notes:
Age gap relationship hysteria demonstrates the strength of the taboo around pedophilia. Women now call men who date younger women pedophiles, despite both parties being adults, because they know it’s the worst label one can receive. They hope it will shame men into dating women their own age.
It doesn’t work though. Nobody thinks a 40 y/o man dating a 22 y/o is a pedophile. The women are just jealous they’ve hit the wall but the men haven’t, and they are greatly displeased with the way Mother Nature works. (… and Mother Nurture too, because likely their bitter or misguided Moms didn’t explain the Birds & Bees very well.)

If women really are using that term, they are diluting the meaning, just as "racist" has been long diluted.



* His handle was taken from the great dystopic sci-fi movie Brazil.

Comments:
Moderator
Sunday - July 20th 2025 7:07AM MST
PS: I'm sorry your comment got lost, Jim.

Yes, you've been saying that and I have too. I don't know who's ready to take the MAGA leadership right now. I'm hoping things hold together for a while longer, as, re Job One, Trump has been pretty impressive (if you figure he was BSing about that Big Ag/Hospitality waiver and amnesty). Would anyone else be going this far? If he backs down on deportations (doesn't look like it), then that will definitely be the end of his usefulness, IMO.
Moderator
Sunday - July 20th 2025 7:03AM MST
PS: I enjoyed your links, Adam. That youtube cartoon did a nice job illustrating why MAGA has been disgusted with Trump's dissembling about Epstein. Yes, you can get that air freshener amazon has a 5 pack for 19.95

https://www.amazon.com/Jeffrey-Epstein-Air-Freshener-Pack/dp/B08GFCXB5G?th=1

I wonder if the meme came first or the actual air freshener. 4 bucks a piece - yikes is making a ... errr, killing.
J1234
Saturday - July 19th 2025 12:04PM MST
PS:
Damn, I lost my comment. Sorry. Good article and perspectives, Achmed!

It's been obvious to me for a long time that MAGA (or what it represents) will have to part ways - or outgrow - the Donald. Is this the start of that? I'll be watching with interest.

Jim
Adam Smith
Saturday - July 19th 2025 12:01PM MST
PS: Afternoon, y'all...

https://i.ibb.co/qLd5pDSR/Air-Freshener.jpg
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G4LSLJLv87M

Cheers! ☮️

Moderator
Saturday - July 19th 2025 8:07AM MST
PS: As the first "Woman President"(?), Trump does tend to fly off the handle sometimes, SafeNow. Will he say something completely different to MAGA when his mood changes?

He's used to MAGA supporting him with everything we've got, some blindly, as if he could do no wrong. The Iran bombing turned off some of the people to some degree. His visible support of Lindsey Graham may have pissed off some more of us. We could chalk that up to political expediency or something, but Miss Lindsey is not MAGA material. Well, I'll write a post on this...

That's interesting, the concept you brought up from John Updike's book.
Moderator
Saturday - July 19th 2025 7:38AM MST
PS: I read this yesterday, Mr. Hail. I probably don't keep up as much as you do with the Yuge MAGA reaction. I'm sure the left hopes that this is Trump's downfall. I really hate seeing the guy lie obviously and directly like he did here. MAGA also sees this as the end of any effort to root out the Deep State, I guess. To me, that latter is the crux of the matter.

We could put up with another lying politician if he's still doing Job 1 because he really does care about the future of White America. (Though I guess it's still not as much as he cares about himself and his feelings - as per SafeNow in the next post.)

I'll have a post coming on this. I could paste in yours too, before that, if you're OK with it. Today I'll just have something short and not so important, and there's plenty more stupidity around.

Nothing is new on your site, BTW. Do you have anything coming?
SafeNow
Saturday - July 19th 2025 12:54AM MST
PS
In analyzing this rupture of the bonds of affection between Trump and his supporters, Updike’s “Rabbit at Rest” came to mind for me. This 1990 novel was widely praised as “the best postwar novel,” and so the concepts observed and developed by Updike deserve our consideration. (Yes, when the literary critics coined the term “postwar,” they had no idea what was coming.)

Rabbit was deeply offended by the fact that his wife refused to do for him that certain thing which is really important and needed for a man. (I can hear you think, but it’s not that.) Rather, it is to tell Rabbit, repeatedly, that he is ….Terrific! Rabbit acknowledges that he is not actually so terrific, but this just makes it even more important to hear it.

When Trump acrimoniously and condescendingly tells Maga, you idiots, CPT is not worth continuing to worry about, he is telling them that they are not being terrific. To MAGA this is a very serious marital problem. And, it works the other way too. Trump needs to hear, from his followers - - constantly - - that he is terrific. If “his wife” has stopped telling him this, he will be motivated to change his behavior…. so that he can hear it. It is highly important to him …on the level of feelings. This is not only politics….this is feelings. (Disclosure: Old psych major.)

Hail
Friday - July 18th 2025 11:46PM MST
PS

See my comment titled "CPT vs CRT", here:

https://peakstupidity.com/index.php?post=3301

(written about the same time as this post, I think.)
WHAT SAY YOU? : (PLEASE NOTE: You must type capital PS as the 1st TWO characters in your comment body - for spam avoidance - or the comment will be lost!)
YOUR NAME
Comments